Connect with us


Document shows Liberals knew $50 a tonne charge wouldn’t reduce carbon emissions

Publication of the report was delayed until June 14, six months after the cabinet announced a steep increase in the tax.




The feds knew charging $50 a tonne would not meet carbon emission targets, even though then-Environment Minister Catherine McKenna repeatedly promised prior to the 2019 election the rate would never increase, says Blacklock’s Reporter.

“The Department of Environment projections suggest the current level of carbon pricing contained in these projects is insufficient to reduce emissions,” said the Expert Assessment Of Carbon Pricing Systems.

Publication of the report was delayed until June 14, six months after the cabinet announced a steep increase in the tax.

The report was “the first comprehensive assessment of the carbon pricing systems that have been designed and implemented,” wrote researchers. Analysts called carbon taxes “a mashup of design choices” that would have not have worked at the $50 cap promised by cabinet.

“Carbon pricing in Canada within the last four years has been in a constant state of flux,” said the report.

Parliament in 2019 passed the Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act that set the $50 cap, the equivalent of 12 cent per litre of gasoline. Cabinet pledged it would never increase.

“The price will not go up,” then-Environment Minister Catherine McKenna said June 13, 2019.

“The plan is not to increase the price post-2022. We are doing exactly what we said we’d do.”

Liberal MP Sean Fraser (Central Nova, N.S.), parliamentary secretary for finance, told reporters July 9, 2019: “This is not some sort of election trickery.”

But cabinet last December 11 abruptly announced a 240% increase in the tax to $170 per tonne, rising by $15 increments beginning in 2023.

The higher charge is the equivalent of a total 27 cents more per litre of propane, 34 cents per cubic metre of natural gas, 40 cents more per litre of gasoline, 44 cents for aviation fuel and an extra 47 cents per litre for diesel.

Cabinet in a secret memo obtained by Blacklock’s in 2017 stated a carbon tax of at least $100 was needed to meet emission targets by 2020, and as much as $300 by 2050 but the Environment department at the time dismissed the memo as speculative.

“Existing greenhouse gas regulations should continue and could be tightened,” said the memo.

“Regardless of federal carbon pricing systems, (we) likely need complementary measures to meet ambitious targets … in sectors and areas not covered by pricing, and to counteract other barriers to reductions not fully addressed by pricing.”

McKenna at the time maintained the carbon tax was “the cheapest way to reduce emissions,” but never publicly acknowledged he knew the $50 tax cap was insufficient.

Dave Naylor is the News Editor of the Western Standard

Dave Naylor is the News Editor of the Western Standard and the Vice-President: News Division of Western Standard New Media Corp. He has served as the City Editor of the Calgary Sun and has covered Alberta news for nearly 40 years. dnaylor@westernstandardonline.com

Continue Reading


  1. Dennis

    June 23, 2021 at 1:03 pm

    Sorry Dave, this is not news. Everyone in the country, Alberta for sure, knows this bunch are corrupt liars.

  2. Left Coast

    June 23, 2021 at 9:38 am

    CO2 is NOT Carbon . . . Coal is Carbon. CO2 is a benign gas that enables plants to grow.

    That being said . . . the AGW crowd has been lyin to us for 30 years. Wild predictions that never happen, Imaginary Greenhouses made of practically Nothing . . . and low intellect Politicians like our Crime Minister and Klimate Barby repeating nonsense over & over.

    Pollution has practically disappeared in Canada . . . back in the 1970s it was a real problem, not so today. Why would it make sense for Canada that produces 1.5% of Global Emissions to send Cash to China & further cripple our Industry & Population when China increases their Emissions every 20 Weeks by MORE than Canada’s Annual Emissions?

    We are not the Polluters, China & India are the worst on the Planet . . . when they catch up to us . . . we can talk.

    Windmills & Solar Panels . . . made with toxic materials off shore are certainly no answer to a country that is already 75% Green Energy.

    Carbon Sequestration is another Insane Idea . . . CO2 enables Plants to process their food, in a country filled with Wheat Fields and Trees . . . WHY would we try to starve them?

  3. Kelly Carter

    June 22, 2021 at 11:45 pm

    No surprise here. Anyone who ever thought it would stay at $50/tonne was a fool. More importantly that cheque you get back as a “full” refund… No one ever said that would continue either.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


SLOBODIAN: Decade long investigation into Manitoba residential school involves nearly 100 officers and 700 interviews

The First Nation recently undertook a search of the site using ground-penetrating radar technology but has not released the results.




A “large and complex” decade-long investigation by RCMP has been underway into allegations of sexual abuse at a former residential school in Manitoba’s Sagkeeng First Nation.

The Fort Alexander Residential School opened in 1905 on Sagkeeng First Nation, located 120-km north of Winnipeg. In 1970 it was converted to a day school that operated for several years.

Manitoba RCMP issued a press release Tuesday confirming the major crimes unit began looking into allegations of abuse in February 2010, then launched a formal criminal investigation the following year.

RCMP began by gathering information, including reviewing archival records in both Ottawa and Manitoba. They went through thousands of documents such as student and employee lists and quarterly returns.

This involved more than 80 officers who interacted with more than 700 people across North America in an effort to find possible victims and witnesses.

“After compiling and collating all this data, investigators developed an investigative plan that began with the canvassing of people whose names had been identified in the documents as well as a door-to-door canvas in the Powerview/Fort Alexander area, where the school had been located,” said the statement.

The criminal investigation launched in 2011 involved 75 formal witnesses and victim statements.
Recently, Sagkeeng Chief Derrick Henderson said elders and survivors have long spoken about abuse at the school and children that went missing.

The First Nation recently undertook a search of the site using ground-penetrating radar technology but has not released the results.

“Violation of the privacy rights of those involved in this investigation will not only cause further trauma to everyone involved, but also potentially compromise this highly sensitive investigation,” said Henderson. “We ask that the trauma our community has experienced and continues to live every day is respected and that those affected are afforded their privacy at this time.”

RCMP are working closely with First Nations leaders and no other criminal investigations into former residential schools are underway in Manitoba, said RCMP.

Slobodian is the Senior Manitoba Columnist for the Western Standard  lslobodian@westernstandardonline.com

Continue Reading


BC increases vaccine efforts amid slowing rates, including ‘vax vans’

“Over the next two weeks, BC will push hard to vaccinate as many eligible people as possible.”




BC health officials want more people rolling up their sleeves for the COVID-19 shot, and say they will be increasing efforts in the coming weeks to do just that.

Dr. Bonnie Henry, Health Minister Adrian Dix, and Dr. Penny Ballem addressed BC’s vaccine roll-out plan during a Tuesday morning news conference.

Among their announced efforts are “walk-in Wednesday” which will take place August 4 when 20,000 jabs will be made available with no need to book in advance.

Walk-in Wednesday is part of the “Vax for BC” campaign.

“I’d like to begin by thanking each and every one of the millions of British Columbian’s, like me, who have stepped up to be vaccinated,” said Henry.

“Because of this small act, we have been able to re-open our province.

“While we have made tremendous progress with our immunization plan, there is of course more work to do. We know that some people still struggle to find a convenient time in their day to get immunized, and others may still have questions, and be hesitant about the vaccine.

“So starting today, we are making it even easier for people to get vaccines. To help protect themselves, and their loved ones against COVID-19.”

Henry said the province will be introducing “custom vax vans” so people will be able to get vaccinated on their lunch break or “while cooling off at a lake.”

The province is also reducing the wait time between first and second doses from eight weeks to seven weeks.

There are currently 906,772 eligible people who have not received a dose, roughly 19.6% of the population older than 12, according to data from July 23.

Interior health has an un-vaccinated population of 26.2% while Northern health has 32.5% without a first shot.

On Monday, the Surrey Board of Trade wrote a letter to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, Health Minister of Canada Patty Hajdu, BC Premier John Horgan, and Minister of Health Adrian Dix urging them to “implement a proof-of-immunization model.”

“We support a centralized, Canada-wide approach to COVID-19 proof-of immunization that could be easily used to confirm vaccination status for international and domestic use,” said Anita Huberman, CEO, Surrey Board of Trade.

“Without inter-provincial harmonization, Canada risks a piecemeal approach, making life more difficult and unpredictable for individuals and employers during an already uncertain time.”

Last week, YVR airport implemented separate lines for vaccinated and un-vaccinated individuals prior to reaching customs.

The separation of lines – which was put in place as a federal policy – has since been removed following extensive public push-back.

As for enforcing proof-of-immunization policies at concerts, night clubs, and sporting events – an increasing number of British Columbian’s are cozying up to this idea.

Reid Small is a BC correspondent for the Western Standard

Continue Reading


Feds silent on $120M loan to company not ‘worthy of taxpayers’ largesse”

Both CMHC and the Department of Social Development declined to respond to questions.




Federal agencies yesterday remained mum about a $120 million housing loan to one of Canada’s wealthiest developers, after Cabinet earlier defended the loan as critical, said Blacklock’s Reporter.

“This project will help over 300 local families find rental housing units,” Ahmed Hussen, minister responsible for housing, told reporters. “That’s why the government is taking action to increase the supply of rental housing through projects like the one we’re announcing.”

Cabinet on July 19 announced the $120 million loan to build 302 apartments in Brampton, Ont. The developer is Choice Properties Real Estate Investment Trust. The company’s CEO was paid $3 million in salary and benefits last year, according to corporate filings.

“This project will help over 300 local families find rental housing units,” Hussen’s department said in a statement. “A solid and reliable supply of rental housing is critical to ensuring more Canadians have access to housing that is affordable.”

Choice Properties is owned by George Weston Ltd. The developer’s 2020 net income totaled $451 million. The loan was approved through a federal program, the Rental Construction Financing Initiative, that extends 10-year, easy-term credit “for certainty during the most risky periods of development,” according to Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation.

Both CMHC and the Department of Social Development declined to respond to questions. The news website Press Progress cited data from Canada Mortgage and Housing that of 302 apartments in the Brampton project, as few as 61 would rent at below-market rates. The building is scheduled for completion by 2023.

“We know that finding an affordable place to live is a challenge for many Canadians in communities across the country,” Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said at the time. “Today’s announcement is great news for families in Brampton. The Government of Canada will continue to invest to increase affordable housing options.”

George Weston Ltd. reported net earnings of $1.6 billion last year. It also operates the Loblaw Companies Ltd. supermarket chain that in 2019 received a $12 million federal grant to install new freezers. “Canadians might wonder why the Liberals handed over $12 million to Loblaw’s, one of Canada’s richest companies,” Conservative MP Mark Strahl (Chilliwack-Hope, B.C.) earlier told the Commons.

The freezer grant was paid under a Low Carbon Economy Fund. A now-disbanded ecoEnergy program similarly paid grants to large corporations in the name of energy efficiency.

Sobeys Inc. received $1.48 million in ecoEnergy grants in the period from 2006 to 2013. Loblaw Companies received $801,000. A total $207,968 was paid to McDonald’s Restaurants and $153,960 to Sears Canada.

“These companies are flush,” Liberal MP John McKay (Scarborough-Guildwood, Ont.) said in an interview at the time. “Companies, given their financial statements, don’t seem to be worthy recipients of taxpayers’ largesse.”

Mike D’Amour is the British Columbia Bureau Chief for the Western Standard.

Continue Reading

Recent Posts

Recent Comments


Petition: No Media Bailouts

We the undersigned call on the Canadian government to immediately cease all payouts to media companies.

163 signatures

No Media Bailouts

The fourth estate is critical to a functioning democracy in holding the government to account. An objective media can't maintain editorial integrity when it accepts money from a government we expect it to be critical of.

We the undersigned call on the Canadian government to immediately cease all payouts to media companies.

**your signature**

The Western Standard will never accept government bailout money. By becoming a Western Standard member, you are supporting government bailout-free and proudly western media that is on your side. With your support, we can give Westerners a voice that doesn\'t need taxpayers money.

Share this with your friends:


Copyright © Western Standard New Media Corp.