fbpx
Connect with us

Opinion

MORGAN: Anger isn’t enough. Sovereigntists need organization.

The problem is, unless this anger is organized into something cohesive, it won’t be going anywhere.

mm

Published

on

The West is furious and the rage is still blazing hot. The internet is boiling over with secessionist sentiment while hastily organized meetings are packing halls. Western independence supporting websites are being formed, parties are being proposed and groups are starting speaking tours.

The problem is, unless this anger is organized into something cohesive, it won’t be going anywhere.

Anger always fades in time and unless it is harnessed early in order to turn it into something lasting, it is simply a wasted emotion.

In looking at the political landscape in the West right now, I envision an anthill that has been stirred by a stick. Thousands of ants scurry in all directions in rage at the indignity inflicted upon the home they worked so hard to build. Eventually the ants calm down and rebuild their hill which remains as vulnerable to future attacks as it ever has been.

In doing a short search of Facebook, I found more independence leaning groups than I could count. While most of these groups number in the thousands of supporters (as far as online support is concerned), they seem to be little more than repositories of anti-Trudeau memes and conspiracy theories. They are places where people can vent their rage to each other but they are not going anywhere.

Pages and groups claiming to by the Alberta Independence Party (source: Facebook)

As far as independence minded political parties go in Alberta, they are either inactive or in turmoil. No less than three Facebook pages claim to speak for the Alberta Independence Party which appears to be fronting a new board and leader every few weeks or so. The Freedom Conservative Party, Alberta Advantage Party Alberta Reform Party all appear to be spinning their wheels.

The “Wexit” gang is proposing forming yet another provincial party if Jason Kenney dares to refuse to embrace their list of demands (he won’t).

Meanwhile, “Wexit” held a well attended townhall meeting where the Canadian flag was hung upside down and under a pair of Alberta flags. Brilliant strategy right before Remembrance Day.

I know, I know. The hanging of an upside down flag is the international symbol of distress. That tends to apply to countries undergoing a military coup however; not the re-election of a blackface-wearing imbecile. Stunts like that only make the group look like petulant children and will not draw the broader support that they need if they really want to go somewhere.

Gathering 700 people into a capacity room on a Saturday night is impressive. Citizens are looking for a movement to join and support in the long run. I am sure that a great mailing list was compiled and some funds were raised. It has to be remembered though that there are 4.3 million Albertans out there and over half of them must be fully won over before independence becomes a reality. Right now the support is not even close.

Wexit rally in Edmonton (source: Wexit Facebook group)

Building a lasting political movement takes years and it takes a lot of work. These are realities that many who are demanding independence don’t want to face. They are howling for a referendum tomorrow.

Well, there are two problems with that. We won’t be holding one, and it wouldn’t even come close to winning. In fact, it’s doubtful that there will even be one on Equalization.

The reality of building a political party is that much of it is tedious and tough.

Look at the evolution of what finally became the United Conservative Party which formed government in Alberta this year.

I got involved with the Alberta Alliance Party in 2002. At that time we had about 3000 members, a lone MLA in the legislature and perhaps a couple thousand dollars in the bank. We pounded the pavement, did flyer drops, and held sparsely attended town hall meetings throughout the province. We sat through long board meetings and painful policy conventions. We lost by-elections and lost our sole seat in the next general election.

We suffered infighting and had our party split when the “Wildrose” group was formed. We finally came together in a merger and formed the “Wildrose Alliance Party” in 2008. That act of unity brought us new funding, new members and new energy which led to a by-election win along with some floor-crossers who built us a modest caucus.

We then moved on to form official opposition, and nearly government. Then, we lost two-thirds of our caucus in the mass floor-crossing of December 2014, and the NDP came up the middle.

If Jason Kenney had not started the ball rolling and gotten the Wildrose and Progressive Conservative Parties to merge, it is not impossible to imagine that we could have suffered under another four years of socialist government in Alberta.

It took leadership, organization and unity in order to unseat the entrenched Notley government.

If the independence movement wants to morph into something real and lasting they would be well served to study that recent chain of political events in Alberta history.

The Freedom Conservative Party and the Alberta Independence Party are sitting on the wall, too afraid to ask anyone to dance.

Yes. A new party can form government. It will take years though and it won’t be easy. Accept that and work from that basis.

The other difficult thing to accomplish will be unity and leadership. There has to be one dominant and overwhelming group which will sweep aside the growing collection of fringe groups. This group has to be rational and has to have a solid plan. This group has to be willing and able to endure the years of dull meetings from which a lasting foundation can be built.

I don’t see this group coming together in Alberta yet.

Anger alone will make for some great rallies and meetings. Unless a leader emerges to form a solid base and plan from these gatherings, the anger will fade like a fart in the wind and nothing will change in the long run.

Continue Reading
2 Comments

2 Comments

  1. A. B Cutterwood

    November 5, 2019 at 11:43 am

    “Anger always fades in time unless it’s harnessed“. I don’t think that is going to be the case this time because it’s not like people are going back to their jobs next week or anytime soon… Every day that goes by with less and less food on the table and the repo man coming daily for your stuff is going to cause this anger to simmer until the meat falls off the bone.. it is true that the spirit is willing but the flesh is weak mentality on Independence may be the case until the trickle down poverty effect has touched each and every soul in this province… Alberta GDP is $331 billion a year and even with making mistakes as a new country that is enough cushion for slightly over 4 million people to be pretty quick on the uptake side of the learning curve.. I don’t know how the author of this piece can still bang a drum for confederation when club Canada laughs as they take our money and encumbers any efforts for the future with legal binding that even the blind us could see the direct result of those efforts from the feds is poverty for the west… Scott Moe represents his province far better than Kenny is looking after his… Scott Moe understands the position that his farmers are in after losing the biggest customer they ever had to Justin’s inability to handle foreign affairs with China.. Scott pulls absolutely no punches not only when he reflects the rage of his province or when he stands up for the people that elected him to take them forward with their best interests being the only agenda that Scott Moe is concerned with.. this is not missed or overlooked by the people of Alberta watching and listening to Jason Kenny’s half measures hoping this will all go back to sleep wondering if he made a mistake coming to Alberta to usurp the Wild Rose party.. Kenny better get on board or he may be watching the future of this province from the sidelines.

  2. A. B Cutterwood

    November 5, 2019 at 11:17 am

    We haven’t got a couple years and what Kenny should consider doing right now is setting up a pension plan that mirrors Québec’s and start collecting federal taxes… That will make the federal government set up and take notice that we are for real if we can get that accomplished this go around that will not only give us some credibility as to who we are but it will strengthen our position.. Add to that a provincial police force that will replace the obsolete RCMP Who is more suited in a federal position anyway.

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

Opinion

LOGAN: It’s time to divest from Suzuki

“It’s time to send a message to Suzuki where it will hurt the most – his donors.”

mm

Published

on

Eco-alarmist David Suzuki has become more than just your everyday environmental activist — he’s become a well-known Canadian brand.

And it’s a brand that helped create the David Suzuki Foundation, which in 2020 raised more than $13 million for various environmental causes.

But what happens when the namesake of your charitable foundation not only feeds into, but repeats the dangerous rhetoric being employed by extreme environmental groups like Extinction Rebellion?

It was at an Extinction Rebellion event in Victoria in November that Suzuki crossed the line between peaceful activism and extremism.

“There are going to be pipelines blown up if our leaders don’t pay attention to what’s going on,” vowed the 85-year-old activist, best known for hosting CBC’s The Nature of Things.

And he wasn’t ready to back down following the outrage sparked by his comments, telling Victoria’s CHEK News it was “absurd” for people to think he was inciting violence and didn’t regret his comment.

“I meant it. I said it. I regret that the media … would take the context of that article, which was a fine report, and put the headline that totally slants it as if I’m inciting violence,” Suzuki said.

The Foundation that bears his name was quick to distance itself from the co-founder’s comments, saying Suzuki wasn’t speaking on their behalf.

Suzuki eventually apologized for his remarks, saying they were said out of “extreme frustration,” and not meant to support violence.

But despite the apology, Suzuki refused to condemn Extinction Rebellion’s defense of his own comments, which only further raised the temperature.

“Not only will pipelines be blown up, but we can be certain that world leaders will be put on trial for treason or worse — be killed,” said Extinction Rebellion’s National Action & Strategy Coordinator Zain Haq, doubling down on Suzuki’s comment.

It’s time to send a message to Suzuki where it will hurt the most — his donors.

You can send a letter today to the David Suzuki Foundation’s largest donors telling them that his violent rhetoric is unacceptable. Just click on this link.

If activists like Suzuki won’t hold themselves accountable, you can do your part to make them accountable to the people who write their paycheque.

Let these companies and foundations know that it’s time to divest from Suzuki!

Guest column by Shawn Logan with the Canadian Energy Centre

Continue Reading

Opinion

MORGAN: Prepare for National Energy Program 2.0

“Justin Trudeau has never held much love for the prairie provinces and don’t think for a second he wouldn’t repeat the actions of his father with another federal cash grab.”

mm

Published

on

Few people remember the history of Pierre Trudeau’s National Energy Program (NEP) anymore, but we may be doomed to repeat it.

The parallels between the political circumstances leading to the NEP of 1980 and the those of today are chilling.

The most obvious, is that we have another Trudeau at the helm of Canada.

Prior to the mid-1970s, Canada had little interest in Alberta’s oil and gas. While Alberta premiers and business leaders had tried to make a case for Central-Eastern Canada to embrace Albertan hydrocarbon products for decades, they were invariably turned away. We were told our oil was too expensive and impractical to serve the needs of the East. We were instructed to find other investors, and we did.

Alberta oil and gas field development was carried out mostly by American companies in the 1950s and 1960s. Most of our products were sold to American markets including oil shipped through the Transmountain pipeline constructed in 1951. Eastern Canada got their energy products predominantly from foreign tankers and ironically from American sources in the east.

In 1974 everything changed as OPEC imposed an oil embargo in retaliation against countries that supported Israel during the Yom Kippur War. North America was thrown into a prolonged energy crisis as oil shortages hit and costs skyrocketed. While the embargo ended after a few months, OPEC quotas and energy supply manipulations made insecurity a problem for years to come. By 1978 the world price for a barrel of crude oil had risen 700% to $13.54 USD per barrel. The Iran-Iraq war in 1979 cause the price of oil to peak at $40 USD per barrel.

Canadians suddenly discovered the price of oil does indeed impact the price of everything. Inflation that had been problematic became a crisis. The standard of living for Canadians was being impacted and citizens demanded Trudeau (The First) do something, so he did.

With the implementation of the National Energy Program (NEP) in 1980, Alberta’s oil suddenly became Canada’s oil.

Massive tariffs were placed upon oil exports while Alberta was forced to sell oil to the rest of Canada at a mandatory discount. An 8% pre-royalty tax was placed on petroleum and gas revenues and the federal share of petroleum revenues was slated to increase while provinces (mostly Alberta) were to decrease their take. A Canadian ownership levy was applied to multinational companies to try and increase Canadian ownership to 50%. Again, we can’t forget it was Eastern indifference to Albertan oil and gas that created a large amount of foreign ownership in the first place.

The impact on Alberta’s oil and gas sector was immediate and devastating. Companies went bankrupt or fled under the new restrictions. Petro Canada was created as a state-capitalist crown corporation. They couldn’t fill the void left by the companies ruined by the NEP.

The NEP remained in place until 1986. During that period it drained upwards of $100 billion from Alberta while businesses and citizens suffered. Coupled with the high-interest rates of the day, many Albertans were literally forced to walk away from their homes.

Brian Mulroney promised to end the NEP when he successfully campaigned to become prime minister in 1984. Mulroney waited two years before dismantling the program. He only followed through on his promise to Westerners when the price of oil collapsed. And he had devious reasons for it.

Under the NEP, Ottawa placed a ceiling on oil prices, capping how much money Alberta could make. To add a little honey to the vinegar, Ottawa also placed a theoretical price floor, whereby Canada would pay artificially high prices for Alberta oil if prices collapsed.

Mulroney was happy to keep the NEP while prices remained high. As soon as prices fell and Ottawa would have to pay a net-loss for Alberta oil, he got around to keeping his promise.

Alberta was left drained, humiliated, and broke. It took nearly a decade to financially recover.

Fast forward to today and we have another Trudeau in power as world oil prices are spiking. Inflation is reaching levels not seen in generations and the cost of living for Canadians is on the rise. OPEC is actively working to keep oil prices high. Europe is in the midst of an energy crisis while President Biden is begging OPEC to increase oil production in order to bring down world prices. Canadians are starting to raise concerns about the rising cost of living and the government is looking for a source of cash. Carbon-tax happy politicians like Trudeau and BC Premier John Horgan bemoan the high price of gas at the pump, without a hint of irony.

The federal government has been signaling for years they don’t want the West’s “dirty” oil. The Energy East pipeline was and the Teck Frontier oilsands mega-mine regulated to death while Northern Gateway was outright killed. Biden killed the Keystone XL line with nary a peep of opposition from Trudeau while we are being told we must transition away from producing hydrocarbons. Prices for oil and gas were low and we were told demand wouldn’t be returning. That tune may suddenly change.

While rising oil prices are putting pressure on other jurisdictions, they are greatly improving Alberta’s financial outlook. Total government revenue for 2021-22 is forecast to be $14.2 billion higher than initial budget estimates. While the UCP is understandably celebratory with this budget windfall (despite a large deficit remaining), they should keep their celebrations muted. Alberta’s good fortune is also painting a big red target on our back as the federal government desperately seeks revenue sources.

Justin Trudeau has never held much love for the prairie provinces and don’t think for a second he wouldn’t repeat the actions of his father with another federal cash grab.

They won’t call it a national energy program again, but we can expect much the same thing. Western oil and gas producers will be drained in the name of the national interest. Anybody in the West who dares complain of this depredation will be accused of being selfish and heartless.

If and when oil and gas prices return to lower levels, Ottawa will back off and leave the West alone. We will lay besmirched and used again.

This fate doesn’t have to befall us though. We can be proactive rather than reactive for a change.

Western provinces need to demonstrate they won’t take unprovoked attacks from Ottawa any longer. Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe was mocked for saying Saskatchewan must become a nation within a nation, but he is right and is asking for nothing that hasn’t been given Quebec a dozen times over. Nobody is going to look out for the interests of the Western provinces aside from ourselves, so let’s get on with it.

No more talk. It’s time for action. Form provincial pension plans as we withdraw from the CPP. Create provincial police forces as we withdraw from Ottawa’s RCMP. Bring in real citizens’ initiated referenda legislation and don’t be afraid to talk about full sovereignty for provinces as free states. It has to be made crystal clear to Ottawa that another NEP-style incursion upon Western resources will lead to nothing less than the dissolution of confederation. Nothing short of this will stop the federal government from pillaging us again.

If Premier Jason Kenney wants a path to restoring respect for his leadership, it’s right in front of him. Peter Lougheed’s time in office likely would have been somewhat forgettable had it not been for his battles with Ottawa. Alberta wants a leader who will put Alberta first. Kenney has been less than solid on that front and it is indicated in his abysmal support numbers. So far, he has had little but words and failed court challenges for Ottawa.

Demand Kenney either stands up with strength for Alberta, or make it clear he will be replaced by a leader who will.

Otherwise, we will indeed be doomed to repeat history.

Cory Morgan is Assistant Opinion & Broadcast Editor for the Western Standard
cmorgan@westernstandardonline.com

Continue Reading

Opinion

SLOBODIAN: Manitoba’s Keystone Party to focus on grassroots

Now that’s a refreshing concept for Manitobans who got bitterly fed up with the iron-fisted approach of former premier Brian Pallister a.k.a. dictator.

mm

Published

on

Interim leader Kevin Friesen understands why the Keystone Party of Manitoba is perceived as far right-of-centre.

“The parties in Manitoba have moved so far to the left that everybody’s going to see us as a rightwing party.

“We like to call ourselves centre,” Friesen told Western Standard.

He’d like to clear up a misconception promoted by left-wing professors some media tend to breathlessly run to for biased opinion. 

“We’ve been labelled as an unvaccinated, anti-mask party and that’s totally wrong.”

Another thing, Keystone is not affiliated with the federal People’s Party of Canada.

“We we’re getting confused with the PPC and we didn’t want that to happen.”

For some, the confusion stemmed from both party logos sporting the color purple.

So then, what is Keystone all about?

“This is a true grassroots party. Everyone says they want to be grassroots, but nobody’s been that yet. That’s our real focus.

“The real problem is that the accountability from our leaders isn’t being respected. We need someone who is more transparent, more accountable. We’ve always looked for honesty and that seems to be an impossible thing to find in politics nowadays. I hope that’s something that we can bring to the province.

“We need to create a stronger, united Manitoba. But most importantly, we would lead our province and not rule it.”

Now that’s a refreshing concept for Manitobans who got bitterly fed up with the iron-fisted approach of former premier Brian Pallister, a.k.a. dictator.

Although his replacement, Premier Heather Stefanson, promised a change in management style and a more “collaborative approach,” she has yet to convince Manitobans — who call her as ‘Pallister in a dress’ or ‘Pallister in pantyhose’ — that their voices will be heard.

Reeves, mayors, business people, union leaders, indigenous leaders, and Manitobans from diverse backgrounds disenchanted with the Progressive Conservatives fiscal and COVID-19 policies are paying attention to and signing on with Keystone which got started in early 2021.

“I’m the only farmer on the board,” says Friesen from south-central Manitou. 

“We’re finding there are a lot of people from the extreme left, from the NDP and Liberal community, that are interested in what we’re doing and are signing our petition and are saying ‘We’ll support you.’

“It’s not only one area of Manitoba. We’re pretty spread out from Winnipeg to Brandon, north of Dauphin to Southern Manitoba.”

Several Keystone supporters started out backing Manitoba First, formerly the Manitoba Party, and “learned early on it was on a mission to be a top-down party.”

They explored trying to “fix the PC party from within,” but doubted that would work considering “what goes on behind closed doors,” said Friesen.

Keystone is gearing up to field candidates in the 2023 provincial election. But first, it must gather the 2,500 signatures required to register as a political party.

“It would be an awesome Christmas gift to be registered. We’d like to go to Elections Manitoba, not with 2,500 signatures, but 10,000 would be our goal.” 

Keystone’s website promotes fiscal conservative policies and a reduction in the size of government.

In an October 30 video address, Friesen took aim at the PC’s destructive COVID-19 measures. He stipulated Keystone was not formed because of these policies, rather because of the way they were developed and enforced.

“This government has promised to deliver, but it has only mandated. It has stopped businesses from paying their bills to the point of bankruptcy.

“It has divided marriages to the point of divorce and broken relationships of every friend, neighbour, and business partner to the point of tattle-taling and ultimately suicide.”

The immediate goal is to get registered. 

“Then we’ll need to hold a leadership race. I’m not sure Kevin Friesen will be part of that race. The last step would be to have a convention and make sure we do exactly what the members want. We’re gathering a lot of information on what we think Manitobans want.

“This party’s going to lead and not rule and we’re going to do that with integrity.”

One thing that sets Keystone apart from other parties now is the recall clause in its constitution.

“The steering committee made a recall clause in the constitution to hold a leader in check. That creates a prolific new attitude in leadership. It changes the whole way a leader of a party leads his or her team.

“I don’t know of any other party in Manitoba that has a recall clause on their leader. That makes us 100% grassroots and different.”

Friesen knows new provincial parties start up all the time and get nowhere fast because they forget the grassroots.

But he’s convinced, based on the growing and diverse support Keystone is gaining, that the PCs, NDP, and Liberals have something to be very concerned about.

It’s possible. There is no question Manitoba voters are an increasingly disenchanted lot.

Slobodian is the Senior Manitoba Columnist for the Western Standard
lslobodian@westernstandardonline.com

Continue Reading

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

Share

Petition: No Media Bailouts

We the undersigned call on the Canadian government to immediately cease all payouts to media companies.

798 signatures

No Media Bailouts

The fourth estate is critical to a functioning democracy in holding the government to account. An objective media can't maintain editorial integrity when it accepts money from a government we expect it to be critical of.

We the undersigned call on the Canadian government to immediately cease all payouts to media companies.

**your signature**



The Western Standard will never accept government bailout money. By becoming a Western Standard member, you are supporting government bailout-free and proudly western media that is on your side. With your support, we can give Westerners a voice that doesn\'t need taxpayers money.

Share this with your friends:

Trending

Copyright © Western Standard New Media Corp.